Rove met with jeers at U of Iowa [with video]
James Heggen and Rashah McChesney
|
IOWA CITY - Of an audience of 1,200 people, 41 gave Karl Rove a standing ovation, about 30 walked out in protest and one woman tried to arrest him.
Before his appearance at the University of Iowa on Sunday, protesters shouted chants calling Rove, former deputy chief of staff and senior adviser to President George W. Bush - a "war criminal" - among other things.
At the entrance to the Main Lounge of the Iowa Memorial Union, where Rove spoke, two campus police officers searched spectators' jackets, bags and pockets before letting them in. Signs on the doors and windows warned that audience members could not bring in cameras or other video or audio recording devices.
All of the media outlets present were allowed to record and photograph the presentation during the first five minutes, after which they were asked to leave all of their equipment in one corner of the room. UI-TV was allowed to record the entire event to be broadcast at a later date.
In a previous interview, Sharon Benzoni, student and co-chairwoman of the U of I lecture committee, said Rove, who was paid $40,000 for his appearance, initially did not want to allow media personnel to attend at all.
After an introduction by a member of the lecture committee was met with a mix of loud derision and standing ovations, Rove walked onstage and a number of groups exploded into action.
Members of about 30 groups stood and turned their backs to the stage before walking out of the room.
David Goodner, of the University of Iowa Antiwar Committee, said he stood and left in protest because of Rove's "direct and intimate involvement with misleading [the] country into a war with Iraq."
While the protesters filed out of the room, Kirk Brown and Mona Shaw, both of Des Moines, made their way to the front of the room. Shaw read loudly from a piece of paper her intent to place Rove under citizen's arrest.
After university officials spoke briefly with Shaw and Brown, they were escorted from the room.
Frank Durham, associate professor of journalism and communication at the University of Iowa, tried to interview Rove but had a difficult time since the audience was loud and Rove often talked over him.
Durham then moderated a question-and-answer session that took up the bulk of the duration of Rove's appearance. During the session, several more students took the opportunity to heckle Rove.
Rove took most of the jeers in stride. After one member of the audience called out for the $40,000 used to pay Rove to be refunded, Rove succinctly replied, "Can't have it."
After another member yelled that Rove had "blood on his hands," Rove showed the palms of his hands - which had no blood on them in any literal sense - to the audience.
However, one comment left Rove unsettled. An audience member asked a question about gay marriage. He mentioned Rove's deceased father, who the audience member said was gay. Rove sharply responded, "Have you met my father?"
Sharon Benzoni, student chairwoman of the lectures committee said that, though the first minutes were "rowdy," the crowd seemed to calm down enough to allow the presentation to proceed.
"Once they had the chance to get out their angry comments, a really interesting dialogue developed between Rove and the audience," Benzoni said. "It was more antagonistic than I expected; I guess I should have expected it.
"I'm just really glad that when it got to the question-and-answer, the audience was really respectful of both the question and the answers."
Pat Miller, director of the lectures program at Iowa State, said that, despite some controversial speakers, Iowa State hasn't had the kind of audience reaction seen at Iowa on Sunday. When Christopher Hitchens gave a lecture titled "How Religion Poisons Everything" in fall 2007, Hitchens was surprised at the lack of animosity.
"It's like Christopher Hitchens said: 'You're all entirely too nice,'" Miller said.
Terms Of Use
In order to facilitate fair and focused discussion, the Iowa State Daily requires that all participants adhere to the following forum rules. All user feedback will be posted immediately upon submission and will be monitored by the user community. Forum participants are encouraged to report any feedback that does not comply with the rules. Although the Daily reserves the right to remove posts and/or block users if these rules are violated, the staff will not be actively involved in an approval or review process. These terms of use may be modified at any time without notice, and such modifications shall be effective immediately.
All letters to the editor, whether submitted to the online edition or the print edition, and all online story feedback become the property of the Iowa State Daily and may be used in print editions and online editions of the Iowa State Daily. The Daily archives all of its content, which is accessible to readers at any time. Anonymous letters will not be accepted. Names may be withheld for good cause upon request at the sole discretion of the Daily. Letters may be edited for style, space, clarity and accuracy.
In submitting feedback, you are representing and agreeing that:
Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 27
Steve Gregg
posted 3/11/08 @ 4:10 PM CST
What an embarassment to a university supposedly dedicated to free speech and the exchange of ideas to allow lefty radicals to use brownshirt tactics disrupt a speech of their political opponent. (Continued…)
Erik
posted 3/11/08 @ 6:06 PM CST
It would have been interesting to hear what he had to say. Who knows? There might have been something worthwhile. I guess we'll never know now.
Regardless of what you think of the man, you can't deny he has the last laugh here. (Continued…)
Paul Goodman
posted 3/12/08 @ 7:41 AM CST
Free speech doesn't cost $40,000. That is definitely not "free". This is just a cleverly designed way to get paid for doing your own PR. Let's hope Rove donates all his speaking fees to the families of dead soldiers he so passionately cares about. (Continued…)
Paul Goodman
posted 3/12/08 @ 7:48 AM CST
Part of Rove's Heroic Performance @:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=otQyfSYAnTI
lessgov
posted 3/12/08 @ 10:13 AM CST
Some of you seem to think it was OK to attempt to disrupt the speech by Carl Rove.
Some of you use the argument that it is OK because a conservative heckled a liberal at another event sometime. (Continued…)
Steve Gregg
posted 3/12/08 @ 3:48 PM CST
Harry Selby: "What is truly embarrassing is that a major University would pay money to a person whose service to this country has consisted of lying, dividing, manipulating, and jeopardizing national security. (Continued…)
Paul Goodman
posted 3/12/08 @ 11:23 PM CST
Sophie,
I will second that. Your a breath of fresh air on these discussion boards and your questions are appreciated. Furthermore, I believe the words liberal, conservative, right and left have become completely distorted to the point of meaninglessness. (Continued…)
lessgov
posted 3/13/08 @ 7:37 AM CST
Sophie,
Yes my handle does indicate my belief that there should be less government involvement in all aspects of our lives but I don't believe there should be none. (Continued…)
CyRox
posted 3/13/08 @ 10:02 AM CST
I would like to think that, had this event been on the ISU campus, everyone's free speech would be respected: peaceful protesting outside of the venue before and after the speech, allowing attendees to hear both sides and then make their own judgements. (Continued…)
Voice of Reason?
Brad Mills
posted 3/13/08 @ 2:11 PM CST
I see this happen all the time...that is, people mistaking "rights" for "politeness."
Did the students have a right to speak out in that forum? Yes, that is what it was for. (Continued…)
Post a Comment